Is our tech making the world too complex? – Samuel Arbesman – Aeon

Complex Adaptive System

For centuries, humans have been creating ever-more complicated systems, from the machines we live with to the informational systems and laws that keep our global civilisation stitched together. Technology continues its fantastic pace of accelerating complexity — offering efficiencies and benefits that previous generations could not have imagined — but with this increasing sophistication and interconnectedness come complicated and messy effects that we can’t always anticipate. It’s one thing to recognise that technology continues to grow more complex, making the task of the experts who build and maintain our systems more complicated still, but it’s quite another to recognise that many of these systems are actually no longer completely understandable.  We now live in a world filled with incomprehensible glitches and bugs. When we find a bug in a video game, it’s intriguing, but when we are surprised by the very infrastructure of our society, that should give us pause.

via Is our tech making the world too complex? – Samuel Arbesman – Aeon.

As someone who works in information technology, I always find it surprising when people suddenly realize that systems have become too complicated for any one person to understand.  The reality is that any complex computer system is like that, and that it has been a reality for decades.

Anyone who ever had to write relatively simple programs in school has dealt with having to debug them and then, when they appeared to work, having had the uneasy feeling of not knowing exactly how.

Arbesman mentions the railroad as the first complex system that humans couldn’t understand.  I have to disagree.  Before railroads, we had market economies, whose existence we weren’t even conscious of for thousands of years until Adam Smith.  Before economies, we had complex farming ecologies that no really understood.

The fact is, once we settled down and ended our hunter gatherer days, humans have been living with ever more complex systems that we didn’t fully understand.  Certainly the systems these days have become far more sophisticated and complex, but that’s a matter of degree rather than a new phenomenon.

And, of course, we’re helped in dealing with dealing with our ever more complex systems by our ever more complex sophisticated tools, many of which are themselves more complicated than any one person can understand, a fact that I’m sure many people will also find disturbing.

It might help to ponder what the alternative is, to return to a simple life, where everything can be understood, and where life is nasty, short, and brutish.  Living with complicated systems has its drawbacks, but they have to be weighed against the many advantages of such systems.

5 thoughts on “Is our tech making the world too complex? – Samuel Arbesman – Aeon

  1. I agree, our technology has been increasing in complexity since the first Homo habilis that cut himself on a sharp rock and realized that it might help him deflesh a carcass quicker thus enabling him to take home more meat.

    I’ll pass on the “nasty, brutish and short” thanks all the same 🙂


    1. LOLS! Your comment reminds me of this TED* talk by Douglas Adams, where he discusses the first monkeys who used sticks to get at food, and then refers to airplanes and boats as the “latest in stick technology”.

      *Well, it’s on the TED site, although I’m not sure if TED existed yet when he gave this talk.


Your thoughts?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.