Recommendation: Dark Intelligence

I’ve been meaning to check out Neal Asher’s books for some time.  They keep coming up as recommendations on Amazon, Goodreads, and in various other venues, and they sound enticing, like the kind of fiction I’d enjoy.  Last week, I finally read the first book of his most recent trilogy, ‘Dark Intelligence‘.

The universe described in Dark Intelligence has some similarities to Iain Banks’ Culture novels.  Earth lies at the center of an interstellar society call the Polity.  The Polity isn’t nearly as utopian as Banks’ Culture, but it’s similarly ruled and run by AIs.  Humans are still around, but in various combinations between baseline humans and ones augmented in various ways, either physically or mentally.  In this particular novel, most of the action takes place outside of the Polity itself.

The Polity has an enemy, the Prador Kingdom, composed of a brutal crab like alien species called the prador.  The Polity and the prador fought a war about a century before the novel begins, which ended with a tentative truce.  What I’ll call the anchor protagonist, the awesomely named Thorvald Spear, was a soldier killed in the war, but at the beginning of the book is resurrected from a recently discovered mind recording.

It turns out that Spear was killed by a rogue AI named Penny Royal, who also took out a large number of Spear’s fellow soldiers when it went berserk.  Penny Royal is still at large when Spear is revived, and he has a burning desire for revenge, so he sets out to find and destroy it.  His chief lead to find Penny Royal is a woman and criminal boss named Isobel Satomi, who may know the AI’s location because she once visited it to attain new abilities, which it provided, but at a cost.  As a result of receiving those abilities, Satomi is now slowly transforming into an alien predator.

Yeah, obviously there is a lot going on in this book, and everything I’ve just described is revealed in the opening chapters.  The book has a substantial cast of viewpoint characters: humans, AIs, and aliens.  Penny Royal is at the center of several ongoing threads, its actions affecting many lives.  It turns out it is regarded by the Polity AIs as dangerous, a “potential gigadeath weapon and paradigm-changing intelligence”.

There are a lot of references to events that I assume happened in previous books, particularly on one of the planets, Masada.  Somewhere in the book I realized that I had already read about one of the aliens in a short story by Asher: Softly Spoke the Gabbleduck.  He appears to have written a large number of books and short stories in this universe.

I found Asher’s writing style enticing but at times tedious.  Enticing because he enjoys describing technology, weapons, and space battles in detail, and a lot of it ends up being nerd candy for the mind.  Tedious because he enjoys detail all around, often describing settings and characters in more detail than I really care to know, making his book read slower as a result.

Asher also has a tendency to evoke things like quantum computing or fusion power as a means for describing essentially magic technologies.  Much of it is standard space opera fare, such as faster than light travel or artificial gravity.  Some of the rest involve things like thousands of human minds being recorded on a shard of leftover AI material.  This isn’t necessarily hard science fiction, although it remains far harder than typical media science fiction.

But what kept me riveted were the the themes he explores.  The story often focuses on the borders between human, AI, and alien minds.  Satomi’s transformation in particular is described in gruesome detail throughout the book.  (It reminded me of the movie, ‘The Fly’, particularly the 1986 version.)  But most of what makes her transformation interesting, as well as similar transformations other characters are going through in the book, are how their minds change throughout the process.  Their deepest desires and instincts start to change in ways that really demonstrate just how contingent our motivations are on our evolutionary background or, in the case of AIs, engineering.

Not that this book was only an intellectual exercise.  There is a lot of action, including space battles, combat scenes, and AI conflict, not to mention scenes of an alien predator hunting down humans, from the predator’s point of view.

Warning: this book has its share of  gore and violence.  I think it’s all in service to the story, but if  you find vividly described gore off putting, this might not be your cup of tea.

This book is the first in a trilogy, so it ended with lots of loose unresolved threads.  I’ve already started the second book, and will probably be reading a lot more of Asher’s books in the coming months.

9 thoughts on “Recommendation: Dark Intelligence

  1. I have been toying with the Culture series of novels for some years, but something has always put me off reading it. Possibly just the name of the first book, Consider Phlebas. Of the two series (Culture vs Transformation), which would you recommend?

    Liked by 1 person

    1. The Culture novels have been a mixed bag for me. Of the ones I’ve read, the later ones, such as Surface Detail, were a lot more enjoyable than the earlier ones, such as Use of Weapons. I enjoyed the settings painted in the earlier books, but the plots were too psychological and the characters too unsympathetic for my tastes. After reading Consider Phlebas, it took considerable persuasion from one of my friends (an overall Culture fan) to try some of the other books.

      I enjoyed Dark Intelligence more than any of the Culture novels, but it was only the first book, so who knows, although I’m enjoying the second book so far. I’m sure as I go through the Polity novels there will be some I enjoy less. But based on what I’ve read, I generally enjoy Asher’s writing more than Banks’.

      Liked by 1 person

  2. I just finished the third book and you will not believe where the whole thing ends up (with all of the story lines resolved)! I am not sure I believe it, or possibly even understand it.

    I once had the conceit that I could write science fiction. Neil Asher gives the lie to that belief. I don’t have anywhere near enough imagination! Fantastic author. Brings a lot to the table. be sure to have your brain turned on and your seat belt fastened.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thanks. I’m about 40% through the second book, so good to know it’s all going somewhere good.

      I often have that feeling, that there’s no way I could ever produce what I just read. The strongest I ever recalled feeling it was after reading a key chapter in one of George R.R. Martin’s books. But years later I saw Martin admit that he had revised that chapter endlessly until it had the punch he wanted. We sometimes look at the final result and it feels hopeless. But we have to remember that we’re only seeing that final result, not all the intermediate and iterative drafts and revisions that led up to it.


Your thoughts?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.